Friday, 30 July 2010

The Spirit Print E-mail
By Nina Lah   
Friday, 23 January 2009

Image

If you ask me, you'd be better off watching paint dry than The Spirit, where a rookie cop who comes back from the dead to fight crime. Based on the 1940s comic strips by Will Eisner, whose graphic novel Contract With God was acclaimed as the first of its type, this film adaptation offers direction by Frank Miller and an impressive cast. But it’s spoilt by cheesy acting and confusing ideas.

Effort has been put into the comic book look, from black and white visual effects to the piercing red tie of Central City. But frenzied overacting and plotlines–like watching someone 'try' to act themselves acting badly–are impossible to enjoy.

On the face of it the plot is quite simple. The Spirit, a masked crime-fighter played by Gabriel Macht, has charm that makes every woman adore him; he can also heal very fast. Unfortunately The Octopus (Samuel L. Jackson) has the same power (Coincidence? Not really!) and is out to rule the world.

Meanwhile The Spirit gets on with being a true ladies man, though his intentions are not to hurt any of quite a few ladies, including Eva Mendes as Sand Saref, his first love, addicted to everything shiny.

Repeat the name Sand Saref a hundred times. Think that's annoying? Go watch the movie. The lines, like "Shut up and bleed!" are sometimes out of place and sometimes just plain bad.

The mystery, horror, comedy, and romance of the comics have been dumped on screen in a confusing blur. A one-minute romance turns into the Spirit getting stabbed. A minute later the narrative has already moved on to the death of a hero (a second death, I may add). Scenes that should have made sense in context–one employing Nazi uniform and swastikas–seem out of place and potentially offensive.

A romance fan, I would normally be upset at not getting a happy romantic ending, but in this case was not even slightly bothered. The ending leaves room for a sequel but who in their right mind would want to see it?

One star out of five.

Directed by Frank Miller; Starring: Jaime King, Dan Gerrity, Gabriel Macht, Eva Mendes, Samuel L. Jackson, Scarlett Johansson, Sarah Paulson.



  • Please keep the topic of messages relevant to the subject of the article.
Name:
Title:
Comment:



MathGuard security question: 0 + 0 =

 
< Prev   Next >
XBannerB
65 Degrees North helps to get acquainted with the city of Oulu.
 
FeedbackForm