Saturday, 10 January 2009

Chanting and Ululating at ‘Multicultural’ Mothers Day Party Print E-mail
By Edward Dutton   
Monday, 12 May 2008
Image’Multiculturalism’ is starting to go out of fashion in Oulu with more and more columns devoted to criticising it in Kaleva, but this didn’t stop the city’s ’Multicultural Integration Service’ putting on a lively Mothers Day celebration which included Middle-Eastern dancing, Sudanese chanting and free cake to ‘bring cultures together’.

The ‘Multicultural Mothers Day’ celebration took place in the Villa Victor ‘International Activities Centre’ (on Kirkkokatu) and the hall was packed, with quite a few having to stand at the back, with mothers and kids from all over the world: Japan, Sudan, Iraq, India and Turkmenistan to name but a few. 

Multicultural Adoption 

Compered by 24-year-old student and trainee Petri Jukka, the events began with a speech by Oulu priestess Rev. Satu Saarinen, who has recently adopted a two year old South African child. ‘He has another mother but she wanted a better life for him,’ she said, before explaining how great she believed Finland’s social security system to be if you are a mother.  ‘Finnish society supports motherhood very well’ the priestess explained.

‘As a mother I can’t perform miracles but I know that my love is a miracle’ she declared, in speech that moved between Finnish and English.  

Sudanese Chanting 

A number of Finnish violin laments were followed by lively Sudanese dancing, chanting and ululating from members of the city’s Sudanese congregation with their leader, Rev. Amos Manga, drumming away in the background. They danced their way up the aisle at the centre of the room before performing at the front while other Sudanese danced and chanted from within the audience. According to the Sudanese priest, who was ordained in a widely reported ceremony in Oulu Cathedral last June, all of the songs that they performed were ‘about Jesus.’  

The Sudanese spectacular was followed by a group of middle-aged Finnish mothers performing Middle-Eastern dances. The crowd became particularly excited about this light-heartedly erotic display with camera flashes continuously going off throughout as the ladies performed in their ornate costumes. There were then a number of performances by children from the city’s ‘English Language Club.’ This included gymnastics, dancing, singing songs about mothers and various Finnish songs and the reading of a poem in Finnish, by a particular Iraqi girl, about how fantastic mothers are. One mother from Turkmenistan commented on how much more ‘happy’ the foreign performances were than the Finnish violin and piano tunes, most of which were fairly sombre.  

Advising Immigrants 

After the performances finished, people socialised over coffee and a rather nice strawberry and raspberry cake in the foyer of Villa Victor. The area is decorated with various examples of ethnic art and aims to allow immigrants to come and socialise and relax – there are newspapers, magazines and internet facilities.  

In addition, there are other services such as health advice. Even the toilets contained posters telling immigrants that they should remember to wash their hands after using the facilities and that they should remember to use deodorant when they sweat.   

‘What are you supposed to do?’ 

Shahnaz Mikkonen, the event co-ordinator, came to Finland from Iran in 1972. She felt that the event was important because, ‘Many people don’t celebrate Mothers Day as they do in Finland so it’s nice for them because otherwise they wouldn’t get a party like this.’ Mrs Mikkonen disagreed with the view that Multiculturalism is a left wing ‘ideology’ – a view expressed in the Kaleva letters column on various occasions. ‘It’s just nice to bring different cultures together,’ explained Mrs Mikkonen, ‘so we can share with each other and get to know each other through music and celebration.’ In response to those who claim that Multiculturalism has failed she added, ‘It depends how you handle it.’  

She felt that mixing cultures was inevitable and the only way it could be stopped was if foreigners were simply prevented from coming to Finland.  ‘What are you supposed to do? People are going to come,’ she said. ‘Why should only white people be allowed to travel?’ She said that as immigrants are in Oulu they should be helped ‘so that they can integrate and go to work and become well-educated.’ Her ‘hope’ was that ‘events like this’ could lead to better integration and ‘more tolerance’.  

And she added that the Finnish gene-pool is very ‘homogenous’ which leads to ‘sickness’. ‘Letting people in will mean a better genetic future for Finland!’ she smiled.    

‘It doesn’t help them integrate’ 

However, not all sections of the city were supportive of the event. According to Veli-Pekka Kortelainen, the leader of the Oulu branch of the anti-EU party ‘True Finns’ which has five Members of Parliament, ‘An event like that doesn’t help people to integrate into Finnish culture. It helps them to integrate into a kind of mixed salad, multicultural culture but not into Finnish culture.’ He added, ‘It’s a nice idea but all it really does is help minorities to get along with each other . . . not with other Finns’.  

‘Multiculturalism is about looking to other cultures for ideas,’ he claimed, ‘but forgetting about the qualities of our own culture. ‘If someone asks, ‘What value does being a Finn have?’ you should ask them, ‘What value does having your own personality have rather than just being like other people?’




Comments (13)
1. 12-05-2008 22:47
Written by This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it
Ph.D
At the feast there were several Finnish women who liked the feast. One of them to whom this feast was first time to experience such a multicultral Mothers\' Day exclaimed that is was a fantastic occasion and she felt pity for those who did not happen to come to see it. 
 
Moreover, multiculturalism in Finland, or anywhere, is not a matter of fashion. Those claiming so do not know the history of this country. We have had always Same people here, also Gypsies and Tatar muslims, Jews for a couple of centuries. We have always had the Finnish-Swedish minority. Viipuri that belonged to Finland until the end of the Winter war was very multicultural and international.  
 
Several old enterprises, factories and established firms in Finland were originally English, German, Russian etc. Those establishing them integrated (not acculturated) into the Finnish society.  
 
It is very biased to end the article = to have \"the final say\" and \"objective verdict\" from the mind of a person titled \"True Finn\" representing an opinionate political minority and not the Finnish majority. 
 
Finally, diversity of people is not the reason of problems between people but how you treat and react to this diversity. Suspicion breeds suspicion, justice breeds juctice. If you cannot eradicate diversity learn to live in it keeping your own identity and respecting that of others.
2. 13-05-2008 00:50
Written by This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it
Ph.D
How is it 'very biased' to give two opinions? And how does that mean that the writer's giving an 'objective verdict.' It's just giving the other side after side after talking to a woman who who thinks we should be 'multicultural'
3. 13-05-2008 01:23
Written by This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it
Ph.D
'Moreover, multiculturalism in Finland, or anywhere, is not a matter of fashion. Those claiming so do not know the history of this country. We have had always Same people here, also Gypsies and Tatar muslims, Jews for a couple of centuries.' 
 
This is nothing to do with 'multiculturalism.' It is a new thing. Even the word in Finnish is quite new.
4. 13-05-2008 08:10
Written by This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it
Hereditary sicknesses - A bad excuse
"she added that the Finnish gene-pool is very ‘homogenous’ which leads to ‘sickness’. ‘Letting people in will mean a better genetic future for Finland!’" 
 
As a person who knows about Genetics I must disagree with this point of wiew. The homogenous of Finnish culture is not the reason for hereditary sicknesses, which will stay no matter how much Finns would mix with other peoples.  
 
All peoples have their typical hereditary failures. Mixing Finns with other peoples would only widen the scale of hereditary sicknesses in Finland with other people's sicknesses.  
 
Maybe this kind of future 'richness' in hereditary diseaces is what they really mean when saying 'multiculturalism is enriching Finnish society'.  
 
And I agree with 'Juha' too. Giving an opposite opinion does not mean it would be 'a final say' or 'objective verdict' even it would be in the end of an article. There is no such thing in objective journalism as 'final say'. The problem is that Finnish media has still sort of 'Soviet' propaganda machine style of saying things. During the Cold War period they used to end Newspaper articles with quotes from some kind of 'Authority' or 'Expert' as it would be an objective verdict or 'Final Say'.  
 
In western media culture putting an opposite opinion in an article is only a mere demand of objectivity. An article without objective point of wiew is considered as 'torso' or as a bad attempt of propaganda. This is something that still seems to be missing in Finnish media.
5. 13-05-2008 13:12
Written by This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it
Ph.D researcher of concepts and reality
0. I, as a commentator, have a full name, I'm not hiding myself bedind a "first name" and/or a pseudonym.  
 
1. To the person who wants to expel my wife from Finland. This Iranian woman happens to have the Finnish citizenship since 1981 given by president Kekkonen. She would have at least visited Iran but never could because she is persecuted there. She never could go there after her departure in 1972, not even to see her relatives. How long time ago did you see your mother, father and your older brother? 
 
We have three academically educated children two of which are in worklife, one is still studying at a university. Our family is multicultural, speak three different languages (myself six languages) and we think we are quite normal. Are you satisfied?  
 
2. Go and and study the various definitions of multiculturalism, interculturalism, cross-culturalism, transculturalism, internationalization and globalization. Try to understand what they mean and then come back to discuss. It is so easy to divert the discussion of a serious matter into venting of frustrated feelings. 
 
3. Go and read the agenda of the kokoomus-party and the Social Democratic party of Finland and see what they endorse in relation with multiculturalism: same aims and objectives.  
I have and never will have any political opinions, only scientific and rational in these matters. 
 
4. I'm very glad that the article has caused this debate in light of which, I dear to believe, balanced assesments and unbiased opinions will emerge. 
 
5. If we discuss on biculturalism two viewpoints are involved. If we discuss on multiculturalism many more viewpoints are involved. I, personally endorse relative multiculturalism, not absolute one.
6. 13-05-2008 13:18
Written by This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it
!
You don't have to hide your name because you won't be accused of being 'racist' or 'Nazi' by anti-free-speech campaigners such as yourself!
7. 13-05-2008 13:30
Written by This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it
!
Our family is multicultural, speak three different languages (myself six languages) and we think we are quite normal. Are you satisfied?  
 
Why do have such a need show off and boast? So what if you're doing a PhD.
8. 13-05-2008 14:13
Written by This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it
Mister
Dear Reetta Juha and US expat,  
 
I did not at all expect the commentators of this page on multiculturalism to divert the discussion on persons. The issue itself should be interesting enough. My wife is in the middle of a work-day of multiculturalism and cannot participate the discussion. You may say whatever you like of me and my family, I /we will not answer back anymore. Once defended is enough.  
 
Our only interest is to examine the issue of multiculturalism, which is not helped by refering to personalities or other irrelevant matters.  
 
If you take the matter up unbiasedly then we can continue, otherwise not. 
 
Why I mentioned that I am a Ph.D. is simply because the reporter, Dr.X. to whom I sent my first comment after reading the article introduced himself as a doctor. So did I to him. And I did not know that my personal comment to him will be published by him on this web page. 
 
People, be they doctors or not, can be narrow-minded or open-minded. Everybody is responsible only for himself/herself.
9. 13-05-2008 15:35
Written by Ed Dutton
Dr
Excuse me! The comment on your PhD has nothing to do with me. You've stated you're a 'PhD researcher' in comment number 6. I presume that is what is being responded to by 'Juha' . And if you are a 'PhD researcher' you are not a 'Dr', unless you already have a PhD in something else or are a medical doctor or, at a stretch, have an honorary doctorate.
10. 14-05-2008 13:39
Written by s'pat
Dr
As a party, why not!!!I think 'multicultural' is a distraction though. Tensions in Kaleva are because people are scared, not in need of new recipes. That's what the internet's for. If you want to make a statement, why not mothers day marathon for cancer, or mothers for more jobs? Less stare at my national dress and more mothers for plates and beds! (Though those costumes do look very fetching...)
11. 16-05-2008 08:42
Written by This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it
A Comment
Since the debate above has been mostly started because of my comment concerning the Mother's Day party, perhaps I should clarify it a bit. 
 
At first, since I did not attend the party, I commented merely the idea of a multicultural feast from the point of wiew of helping integration into Finnish society. I commented the idea of this kind of party, not the specific party that was held (How could I have commented the actuall party since I wasn't there?).  
 
Secondly, I don't deny that maybe in certain preconditions such a party could help integration process. I just think those preconditions do not exist yet, at least not in Northern Finland. 
 
Thirdly, the purpose of my comment was not to raise a quarrel here, and I'm sorry if it did so. 
 
Yours: Veli-Pekka Kortelainen
12. 28-05-2008 10:00
Written by Susan
Biased report
First,the report is provocative,why does the reporter set the party and the debate on Kaleva as oppositions? read the sentence:’Multiculturalism’ is starting to go out of fashion in Oulu with more and more columns devoted to criticising it in Kaleva, but this didn’t stop the city’s ’Multicultural Integration Service’ putting on a lively Mothers Day celebration which included Middle-Eastern dancing, Sudanese chanting and free cake to ‘bring cultures together’. 
2.The reporter is tricky, who put the irrelevant two events and quotes as oppositions.Veli-Pekka Kortelainen 
admits that he didn't specially comment on the party since he didn't even take it. 
3.Free speech can turn to hate speech if the reporter selectively choose irrelevant meterial 
4.This kind of report can lead to panic or even racism between the expatriate community and the local Finnish socity.
13. 30-05-2008 00:30
Written by This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it
Biased report
I don't know why you even write about this event. the event just make the foreigner look like they don't want to integrate. hopefully it will be last event like this.

  • Please keep the topic of messages relevant to the subject of the article.
Name:
Title:
Comment:



MathGuard security question: 3 + 3 =

 
< Prev   Next >
 
What are your intentions for 2009?